ChatMyFood

Weekend overeating: how two days can undo five

🎯 Find out how many calories you should eat every day to lose weight.

You eat carefully from Monday to Friday, relax a bit on Saturday and Sunday, and after a month the scale has barely moved. This is one of the most common reasons a diet stalls, and it shows up in the research as clearly as it does in people’s logs.

What the studies found

A University of North Carolina team (Haines and colleagues, 2003) looked at national food survey data from the mid-1990s. Americans aged 2 and over ate about 82 kcal more on each weekend day, which the authors counted as Friday to Sunday, than on Monday to Thursday. For adults aged 19 to 50 the gap was 115 kcal a day, and a larger share of their weekend calories came from fat and alcohol.

That sounds small, and for an average person eating at maintenance it mostly is. The problem shows up when you are trying to lose weight. In a one-year trial at Washington University (Racette and colleagues, 2008), 48 adults aged 50 to 60 either cut calories or exercised daily. Both groups lost weight on weekdays. On weekends the calorie-cutting group stopped losing, and the exercise group gained about 0.08 kg a day, because they ate more. Before the trial even started, the same people gained about 0.06 kg per weekend day and nothing on weekdays, mostly from eating more on Saturdays and moving less on Sundays. The authors suggest this is part of why weight loss in studies is often slower than predicted.

The weekly maths

A deficit is a weekly number, even if you track it daily. Take someone whose maintenance is about 2,300 kcal (you can estimate yours with the TDEE calculator). They eat 1,800 kcal on weekdays, a 500 kcal deficit, which banks 2,500 kcal by Friday night. Here is what different weekends do to that:

Saturday and Sunday, each day Over maintenance per day Weekly balance Average per day
2,300 kcal 0 -2,500 kcal 1,943 kcal
3,000 kcal +700 -1,100 kcal 2,143 kcal
3,550 kcal +1,250 0 2,300 kcal
3,800 kcal +1,500 +500 kcal 2,371 kcal

Eating at maintenance on the weekend still leaves a solid deficit. Going 700 kcal over each day cuts the week’s loss by more than half. At 1,250 over, five days of effort are gone.

And 1,250 kcal over maintenance takes less than it seems. Half a pizza is four slices, about 1,170 kcal. Three half-litre beers add about 645 kcal. That is one Saturday evening at close to 1,800 kcal, before breakfast, lunch or the snacks during the film. Brunch on Sunday, often cooked in more butter than you would use at home (we covered that in hidden oil calories), can do the rest.

Why the scale jumps on Monday

Orsama and colleagues (2014) analysed 4,657 daily weigh-ins from 80 adults. Weight was highest on Sunday and Monday, started rising on Saturday, and began falling on Tuesday. The people who lost or held their weight over time showed this pattern most strongly, because they came back down during the week. The authors’ advice is to treat the weekend rise as normal variation and to read the trend over weeks.

Much of a Monday jump is water and food in transit. Muscle stores carbohydrate as glycogen, and a 2015 study confirmed the old estimate that each gram of glycogen is stored with at least 3 g of water. A weekend of pizza, beer and bread refills those stores. Salty restaurant food makes you hold extra water for a day or two as well. A two-day surplus of 1,500 kcal is far too little energy to build 1.5 kg of body fat, so most of a jump that size will be gone by Wednesday if the week goes back to normal.

The part that does not drain away is the lost deficit in the table above. The scale recovers by midweek, but the weekly average weight moves down more slowly than your weekday log suggests.

Ways to keep the weekend

Set a weekly average target instead of seven equal days. Coach and researcher Eric Helms suggests that shifting up to about a fifth of a day’s calories from one day to another makes little difference for most people, and that a 7-day average is a fine thing to aim for. Taking 150 kcal off each weekday (about 8% of 1,800) gives you 750 kcal to spread over Saturday and Sunday with the same weekly deficit. That covers a planned dinner out or a couple of drinks. Banking much more than a fifth means very low weekdays, which are harder to keep up and tend to make the weekend bigger.

Eat protein first. A proper breakfast with eggs or yogurt, and the meat or fish part of dinner, leave less room for the 11 pm snack. It also keeps protein steady on days when tracking gets loose.

Choose your drinks with numbers in mind. Pure alcohol has 7 kcal per gram, and a US standard drink of 14 g of alcohol is about 100 kcal before any sugar or carbs in the drink. A 150 ml glass of red wine is about 128 kcal; a half-litre beer is about 215. Spirits with a zero-calorie mixer, or alternating each drink with water, cut the total without opting out of the evening.

Log the weekend, even roughly. “Half a pepperoni pizza and three beers” is a far better entry than nothing, and a rough number with a wide range is still honest data (see why your calorie number should be a range). If your guesses tend to come out low, the calorie quiz is a quick way to check them against real values. Then compare weekly average weights, Monday to Monday. If the trend is flat, the weekend is the first place to look.

ChatMyFood is built for this kind of logging. You can snap a photo or type what you had in a sentence, it shows each estimate as a range, and it asks a short question when one detail (the cooking oil, the size of the glass) would change the number a lot. It is free to try, and you can set up a group with friends or family, which helps when the weekend plans are made together anyway.

Snap your next meal and see the range

ChatMyFood estimates calories from a photo or a sentence, shows how sure it is, and asks about the oil when it matters. Free to try, no card.

Try it free →

How many calories should you eat a day?

Not sure how much you should eat? See your daily calories to lose, keep or gain weight. Free, 30 seconds.

Try the numbers yourself

Sources

  1. Haines, Hama, Guilkey & Popkin (2003). Weekend eating in the United States is linked with greater energy, fat, and alcohol intake. Obesity Research 11(8):945-949
  2. Racette et al. (2008). Influence of weekend lifestyle patterns on body weight. Obesity 16(8):1826-1830
  3. Orsama et al. (2014). Weight rhythms: weight increases during weekends and decreases during weekdays. Obesity Facts 7(1):36-47
  4. Fernández-Elías et al. (2015). Relationship between muscle water and glycogen recovery after prolonged exercise in the heat in humans. European Journal of Applied Physiology 115(9):1919-1926
  5. Scientific Report of the 2020 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee, Part D, Chapter 11: Alcoholic Beverages
  6. Beer, red wine and pizza (USDA FoodData Central, via our food pages)
  7. Helms, Valdez & Morgan. The Muscle and Strength Pyramid: Nutrition (free sample chapter, Behavior & Lifestyle)

General information, not medical advice. If you have a medical condition, are pregnant, or take medication that affects appetite or weight, talk to your doctor before changing how you eat.

More articles

TDEE vs BMR, explained with an honest margin of error5 min readTakeaway calories: pizza, burgers, sushi, curry and more, as honest ranges6 min readProtein to keep muscle while losing weight5 min readPhoto, typing or weighing: which way of logging food is most accurate?5 min read